Have Debt Management Organizations Engaged in Fraud?

Have some debt management organizations engaged in fraudulent activity? The short answer, straight from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), is yes: the Federal Trade Commission has found that some organizations offering debt management plans have defrauded people.

This article explains what that warning means, who it applies to, how a legitimate debt management plan works, and how to vet any debt management company before a single payment leaves your account. It is written for Colorado borrowers who are juggling debt payments and want help without getting burned.

Have some debt management organizations engaged in fraudulent activity?

Yes. On its official credit counseling page, the CFPB states plainly that the Federal Trade Commission has found that some organizations that offer debt management plans have defrauded people.

That is a federal consumer protection agency citing another federal consumer protection agency. It is not internet rumor, and it is not a reason to avoid credit counseling altogether.

The same CFPB page describes credit counseling organizations as usually nonprofit, with counselors certified and trained in consumer credit, money and debt management, and budgeting. The fraud warning exists precisely because legitimate providers and fraudulent companies operate in the same space.

The CFPB’s practical safeguard is specific: if you choose a debt management plan, contact your creditors and confirm that they have accepted the proposed plan before you send any payments to the organization handling your debt management plan.

Before we go deeper, here is the whole picture at a glance.

Quick reference: warning signs vs. what a reputable organization does

Red flag per the CFPB	What a reputable credit counseling organization does
Requires your personal details before sending any information about its services	Sends free information about its services without requiring details about your situation
Charges for educational materials	Offers free educational materials and workshops
Pushes a debt management plan as your only option before analyzing your finances	Offers a range of services, including budget counseling and classes for managing spending and debt
Won’t help you because you can’t afford to pay fees or contributions	Works with you even when fees or contributions are a hardship
Pays employees more when you sign up for certain services or pay a fee	Answers compensation questions openly; no sign-up incentives
Relies on verbal promises	Puts everything in a formal written agreement, including all verbal promises

Every row of that table comes from the CFPB’s own vetting checklist. Now let’s cover what a debt management plan actually is.

What is a debt management plan and how does it work?

A debt management plan is a program a credit counseling organization can organize for all your debts when you are having trouble making payments. According to the CFPB, it typically lowers your monthly payments to creditors as well as interest charges and fees.

The mechanics matter, because they explain where fraud can creep in. Under a debt management plan, you make a single payment to the credit counseling organization each month or pay period, and the organization makes monthly payments to each of your creditors.

That structure puts your money in someone else’s hands before it reaches your credit card companies and other creditors. If the debt management company is fraudulent, the money can simply stop there.

Why creditor confirmation is the critical step

This is why the CFPB’s instruction is so pointed: confirm with your creditors that they have accepted the proposed plan before sending any payments to the organization.

A real plan is one your creditors have agreed to. A fraudulent one often exists only on the paperwork the debt management company showed you.

Next, let’s look at who should take this warning most seriously.

Who does this warning apply to?

The warning applies to anyone considering debt relief help of any kind — credit counseling, a debt management plan, debt settlement, debt consolidation, or credit repair. People under financial stress are exactly who deceptive practices target.

Colorado Springs and military households

Colorado Springs is a heavily military market, and financial strain often spikes around a PCS move, a deployment, or a gap between duty stations. A household scrambling to keep up with credit card debt before a move is a prime audience for debt relief scams.

Service members and veterans should apply the same CFPB vetting steps as everyone else, and can also check any organization with the state attorney general and state consumer protection agency before signing anything.

Homeowners and future homeowners

How you handle debt also touches your mortgage life. Credit counselors can help you get a copy of your credit report and scores, build a budget, and manage debt — all of which feed into the debt-to-income ratio and credit report a lender reviews when you apply for a home loan.

And if the debt trouble involves the mortgage itself, there is a separate, specific path, which we cover below. First, the source material.

What the official source says and where to read it

The authority here is the CFPB’s “What is credit counseling?” page at consumerfinance.gov. It covers what credit counseling organizations do, how to find one, and how to vet one.

Key points from that page:

• Credit counseling organizations can advise you on money and debts, help with a budget, develop debt management plans, and offer money management workshops.
• They are usually nonprofit organizations with certified, trained counselors.
• The Federal Trade Commission has found that some organizations offering debt management plans have defrauded people.
• Before sending payments under a debt management plan, confirm with your creditors that they accepted the plan.

The CFPB also distinguishes a nonprofit credit counselor from a for-profit debt management or relief company, and links to a comparison of credit counseling versus debt settlement, debt consolidation, and credit repair.

With the source established, here is how to actually vet an organization.

How do you vet a debt management company before paying?

The CFPB lays out a concrete process. Start by building a list of candidates, then check each one against federal and state agencies and a list of pointed questions.

Where to find candidates

The CFPB points to the Financial Counseling Association of America and the National Foundation for Credit Counseling as starting points. You can also view a list of approved credit counselors through the U.S. Department of Justice.

Once you have a list, check each organization with your state attorney general and state consumer protection agency to make sure they’re reputable. For Coloradans, that means the Colorado Attorney General’s office.

The free-information test

A reputable credit counseling organization should be willing to send you free information about its services without requiring you to provide details about your situation.

If an organization refuses, the CFPB says to consider that a red flag and go elsewhere for help. It is the fastest filter you have.

Questions the CFPB says to ask

• What services do you offer? Look for a range — budget counseling, classes on spending and debt — not just one product.
• How is counseling offered? In person, by phone, or online; an initial session typically lasts an hour with follow-ups offered.
• Do you offer free educational materials? Avoid organizations that charge for information.
• What are your fees? Ask about set-up or monthly fees and get a specific price quote in writing.
• What if I can’t afford your fees or contributions? If they won’t help you because you can’t pay, look elsewhere.
• Will I have a formal written agreement? Don’t sign anything you haven’t read or don’t understand, and get all verbal promises in writing.
• What are the counselor’s qualifications? Ask about accreditation, certification, and training.
• How are your employees paid? If employees earn more when you sign up for services, pay a fee, or make a contribution, that is a red flag.
• Can you provide contact information for past clients? Organizations should be willing to share referrals.

Those questions double as a scam detector, which brings us to the warning signs themselves.

What are the warning signs of debt relief scams?

Pulled directly from the CFPB’s guidance, these are the behaviors that should send you elsewhere.

Pressure toward one product

Avoid organizations that push a debt management plan as your only option before spending significant time analyzing your financial situation. High-pressure sales tactics aimed at a single product are the opposite of counseling.

Different financial situations call for different tools — a budget, a workshop, a plan, or sometimes a referral elsewhere. A counselor who diagnoses before prescribing is the standard.

Charging for information

Legitimate organizations offer free educational materials. One that charges for basic information fails the CFPB’s test outright.

Fee games and missing paperwork

Most credit counseling organizations are nonprofits, but counselors may charge fees for some services. The protection is transparency: a specific written price quote covering any set-up or monthly fees, and a formal written agreement that captures every verbal promise.

An organization that dodges fee questions, resists putting things in writing, or dangles incentives tied to sign-ups is showing you who it is. Walk away.

Money sent before creditors agree

The most consequential warning sign is structural: any debt management company that wants your monthly payment before your creditors have confirmed acceptance of the plan. The CFPB says to confirm with creditors first, every time.

It also helps to understand what credit counseling is not — which is the next section.

How is credit counseling different from debt settlement and debt consolidation?

The CFPB treats credit counseling, debt settlement, debt consolidation, and credit repair as distinct things, and publishes a comparison explaining the differences between them.

It also draws a line between a nonprofit credit counselor and a for-profit debt management or relief company. Nonprofit status alone does not make an organization trustworthy, and for-profit status alone does not make it a scam — but knowing which model you are dealing with shapes the questions you ask.

Whatever label an organization uses — debt relief services, debt settlement services, a debt management program — run it through the same vetting process: free information up front, fees in writing, qualifications verified, and a check with federal and state agencies.

If the debt causing you trouble is your mortgage, the playbook changes, as the next section explains.

What if the debt trouble involves your mortgage?

The CFPB’s mortgage guidance is specific: if you are having trouble making your mortgage payments, reach out to your mortgage servicer and a HUD-approved housing counseling agency.

The CFPB publishes a how-to guide for finding a HUD-approved housing counseling agency and also lists the HOPE™ Hotline as a resource. Its materials specifically address how to avoid foreclosure and how to spot and avoid mortgage assistance scams — the mortgage-world cousin of debt relief scams.

The same instincts apply: be wary of anyone demanding money up front, promising outcomes, or discouraging you from contacting your servicer directly. Your servicer should try to help you find ways to avoid foreclosure, and you have foreclosure protections under state and federal law.

With the full picture covered, here is your action plan.

What to do next

If you are considering credit counseling or a debt management plan, work this sequence:

• Start with the Financial Counseling Association of America, the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, or the Department of Justice’s list of approved credit counselors.
• Check candidates with the Colorado Attorney General and the state consumer protection agency.
• Ask the CFPB’s vetting questions and get fees and promises in writing before signing.
• If you enroll in a debt management plan, contact each creditor and confirm acceptance before sending the organization any payments.
• If the trouble is your mortgage, contact your servicer and a HUD-approved housing counseling agency.

And if you are working toward a home purchase or refinance in Colorado Springs while cleaning up debt, talk through the timing with a loan officer at 719 Lending. Knowing how a debt management plan and your credit report fit into a future mortgage application helps you sequence the steps instead of guessing.

Frequently asked questions

Has the FTC found fraud among debt management organizations?

Yes. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau states that the Federal Trade Commission has found that some organizations offering debt management plans have defrauded people. That is why the CFPB tells consumers to confirm with their creditors that a proposed plan has been accepted before sending any payments to the organization handling it.

How can I tell if a debt management company is legitimate?

Use the CFPB’s checklist: a reputable organization sends free information without demanding your personal details, offers free educational materials, provides a specific written price quote for any set-up or monthly fees, puts all promises in a written agreement, and can share referrals from past clients. Also check the organization with your state attorney general and state consumer protection agency.

Are credit counseling organizations usually nonprofits?

According to the CFPB, credit counseling organizations are usually nonprofit, and their counselors are certified and trained in consumer credit, money and debt management, and budgeting. Counselors may still charge fees for some services, so get a specific price quote in writing before you commit.

How does a debt management plan work?

You make a single payment to the credit counseling organization each month or pay period, and the organization makes monthly payments to each of your creditors. The CFPB says a plan typically lowers your monthly payments to creditors as well as interest charges and fees — but confirm your creditors have accepted the plan before sending money.

Where do I find a trustworthy credit counselor in Colorado?

The CFPB points to the Financial Counseling Association of America, the National Foundation for Credit Counseling, and a list of approved credit counselors published by the U.S. Department of Justice. Then verify your shortlist with the Colorado Attorney General and the state consumer protection agency.

What should I do if I can’t make my mortgage payment?

The CFPB’s guidance is to reach out to your mortgage servicer and a HUD-approved housing counseling agency. Your servicer should try to help you find ways to avoid foreclosure, you have protections under state and federal law, and the CFPB publishes guidance on spotting and avoiding mortgage assistance scams.

719 Lending Inc., NMLS #1601989 · Equal Housing Opportunity

719 Lending Inc. is not affiliated with or endorsed by HUD, FHA, VA, USDA, CHFA, the CFPB, or any government agency.

Last updated: October 2026